Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §16.1
Translation
1 Finally, after the lawless ones saw that Polycarp's body could not be consumed [a] by the fire, they ordered an executioner [b] to approach and run him through [c] with a short sword. [d] After the executioner did this, a great quantity[e] of blood came [f] from Polycarp's body, so that the fire was extinguished. The entire crowd was amazed that [g] there was so stark a difference between [h] the faithless and the elect.
[a] ??????????? (???????) The proconsul had threatened to consume St. Polycarp with flames in §11.2; here the same word for consume is used showing that the proconsul has been thwarted.
[b] The ????????? was the executioner on hand in the arena who "gave the coup de grâce to wounded gladiators" (BAGD, 443). Indeed, St. Polycarp had taken on a wild lion but the lawless crowd. The executioner came not to end the suffering but to allow the proconsul to not lose control of the crowd that he might save face.
[c] ????????? (????????) to stuff or insert (Liddell, H.G., Intermediate Greek English Lexicon, 594). Liddell further notes, regarding ??? (??? > ???? > ????????), that when used with the dative it may mean to stop or to bung up with, to plug (p 158).
[d] ???????? short sword, dagger (BAGD, 548).
[e] ?????? BAGD, 668.
[f] ????????? ??? "and a dove" is noted in Lightfoot as questionable. The shorter reading being preferred, it is omitted here. Lake writes in a footnote, "This no doubt points to the belief that the spirit appears at death in the form of a bird. Cf. Prudentius Peristeph Hymn. iii. 33." (Apostolic Fathers, vol 2, p 333). Holmes annotates, "The reference to the dove is almost certainly a later addition to the text (possibly by the Pionius mentioned in the last paragraph of the epilogue" (The Apostolic Fathers, 239).
[g] ?? after verbs of emotion (i.e., ????????) is rendered as "that" (BAGD, 219).
[h] ??? ??????? ?????? a difference between someone and another (BAGD, 190), which in this case is between the faithless (???????) and the elect or those God has chose for salvation (????????). Consider Didache 1:1, ???? ??? ????, ??? ??? ???? ??? ??? ??? ???????, ??????? ?? ????? ?????? ??? ??? ????. There are two ways. One is of life and one is of death, and the difference between the two is great (author's translation). See also the Epistle of Barnabas 18:1, ??????? ?? ????? ??? ??? ????. There is a great difference between the two [ways] (author's translation).
About this Piece
Date Published
Topics Covered
In This Series
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §Preface
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §2.1-2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §2.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §2.4
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §3.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §3.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §4
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §5.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §5.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §6.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §6.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §7.1a
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §7.1b
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §7.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §7.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §8.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §8.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §8.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §9.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §9.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §9.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §10.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §10.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §11.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §11.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §12.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §12.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §12.3
- Translation: Martyrdom of Polycarp
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §13.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §13.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §13.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §14.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §14.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §14.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §15.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §15.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §16.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §16.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §17.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §17.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §17.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §18.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §18.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §18.3
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §19.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §19.2
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §20.1
- Translation and Commentary on The Martyrdom of Polycarp §20.2
